Emergency Dentist Rozelle

Amalgam Fillings vs Composite: Safety, Lifespan and Whether to Replace Old Ones

Clinically reviewed by Dr John Dawoud, Dentist, Blue Tooth Dental. Updated 19 November 2026.

Amalgam fillings, the silver fillings many adults have had since childhood, are still an accepted material in Australia in 2026. The Australian Dental Association (ADA) describes amalgam as a safe and acceptable option where clinically indicated, and Australian guidance says intact amalgam fillings should not be removed for vague or perceived health complaints.

What has changed is how rarely amalgam is now chosen. It is being phased down under the Minamata Convention on Mercury for environmental reasons: the European Union ended routine use on 1 January 2025, and a global phase-out date of 2034 was agreed in November 2025.

Composite resin, the tooth-coloured option, bonds to the tooth and needs less drilling, but the strongest trials suggest it fails more often in back teeth. Whether an old filling stays or goes depends on its condition, not its colour.

Key takeaways

  • Amalgam is not banned in Australia. The Dental Board of Australia (November 2022) recommends against it for baby teeth, people under 15 and pregnant or breastfeeding women, unless the dentist considers it necessary.
  • A 2021 Cochrane review found composite fillings in back teeth may fail almost twice as often as amalgam, based on low-certainty evidence from trials in children.
  • Removing a sound amalgam filling cuts away healthy tooth and briefly increases mercury vapour exposure, so guidance advises against replacing intact fillings without a clinical reason.
  • Cracks, decay under the edge, a broken piece or a proven allergy are reasons to replace. Colour alone is a personal choice.

What are amalgam fillings, and what colour are fillings today?

Dental amalgam is a mix of silver, copper, tin and zinc bound with mercury into a stable alloy. It is silver-grey when placed and darkens with age.

The healthdirect guide to dental fillings (reviewed February 2025) notes that amalgam has been used for more than 150 years but is less common today. Most new fillings are tooth-coloured: composite resin, glass ionomer cement or ceramic. At our King Street practice, new fillings are placed in tooth-coloured filling materials and ceramic onlays.

An old silver filling can also leave a blue or grey shadow through the enamel, one of several reasons for a tooth turning blue or grey.

Are amalgam fillings safe? What Australian authorities say in 2026

Australian health and dental authorities do not regard existing amalgam fillings as a health risk for the general population.

  • ADA Policy Statement 6.18 (last amended April 2026): amalgam “remains a safe and acceptable restorative option where clinically indicated”. Set amalgam releases mercury in nanogram amounts, and the evidence does not link it with chronic, kidney or autoimmune disease, cognitive problems or adverse pregnancy outcomes in the general population.
  • The healthdirect fillings guide (February 2025): suitable for most people, though the body can absorb a small amount of mercury from a filling.
  • NSW Health guideline GL2020_015 (July 2020, for public dental clinics): existing amalgam restorations remain safe and should not be removed unless strictly necessary.

Mercury is toxic in high doses, which is why the question keeps coming up, and some groups need extra care.

Amalgam vs composite: how do the two materials compare?

Amalgam lasts longer on average in back teeth and tolerates a wet working field. Composite looks like a tooth, needs less drilling and contains no mercury, but it is more demanding to place and may need replacing sooner.

Feature Amalgam (silver) Composite resin (tooth-coloured)
Appearance Silver-grey metal Shade-matched; can stain or change colour over the years
How it stays in Held mechanically, so extra healthy tooth is often shaped away to lock it in Bonded to the enamel and dentine, so usually less tooth is removed
Longevity evidence Lower failure rate in back teeth (Cochrane 2021, low certainty). SA Dental Service average: about 15 years (accessed November 2026) May be almost twice as likely to fail, with more decay at the edges (Cochrane 2021). SA Dental Service average: 5 to 7 years
Moisture control More forgiving if the tooth gets slightly wet Needs a dry tooth while it bonds, harder in deep cavities near the gum
Cost factors (no prices) Size, surfaces, the tooth, any base or liner Surfaces, layering and curing time, whether an onlay or crown suits better
Suitability, 2026 Rarely used (Better Health Channel, 2025); not recommended for baby teeth, under 15s, or pregnant or breastfeeding women unless necessary (Dental Board, 2022) Front and back teeth; less suited to very large cavities or teeth that cannot be kept dry

Glass ionomer cement is tooth-coloured and releases fluoride but is weaker than composite. Ceramic onlays are made outside the mouth and bonded in, for teeth that have lost a cusp or much of their biting surface.

What the longevity evidence actually shows

The strongest head-to-head evidence is a 2021 Cochrane review comparing composite and amalgam fillings in back teeth. Its main analysis pooled two randomised trials: 921 children aged 6 to 12, with 1,645 composite and 1,365 amalgam fillings.

Composite fillings were more likely to fail (risk ratio 1.89) and to develop new decay at the edges (risk ratio 2.14). There was no clear difference in fractures. The authors rated the evidence low certainty.

The trials were in children, and composites have changed since. A 2014 Journal of Dental Research meta-analysis of 2,816 back-to-tooth composites, followed for at least five years, found decay and fracture caused most failures, more often in people prone to decay and in fillings covering more surfaces. Your decay risk and the filling’s size matter as much as the material.

Is amalgam banned in Australia? Minamata, the EU ban and the 2026 position

No. As of November 2026 dental amalgam is not banned in Australia. It is being phased down under an international treaty, with a global phase-out date of 2034.

The Minamata Convention. Australia ratified this mercury treaty in December 2021, and it came into force here on 7 March 2022, according to the Australian Government treaty record.

The 2034 decision. At the sixth Conference of the Parties in Geneva in November 2025, countries agreed on 2034. The ADA’s report on the 2034 global phase-out date (11 November 2025) explains that manufacture, import and export will then be banned, while dentists may still use amalgam where necessary. The ADA describes this as an environmental measure, not a response to a personal health risk.

The European Union. The EU banned the use and export of dental amalgam from 1 January 2025, except where strictly necessary for a patient’s specific medical needs, under its revised Mercury Regulation.

Australia now. The Dental Board of Australia’s November 2022 position statement says bulk mercury must not be used and recommends against amalgam for children and for pregnant or breastfeeding women (detailed below). Australia’s 2025 national report under the Convention adds two measures: pre-encapsulated amalgam only, and lower mercury releases from dental clinics.

Who is usually advised to avoid new amalgam fillings?

Four groups are usually offered mercury-free material unless there is a specific clinical reason.

  • Children: the Dental Board (2022) does not recommend amalgam in baby teeth or for patients under 15 unless necessary, and it is not commonly used in children, according to healthdirect.
  • Pregnant or breastfeeding women: covered by the same Dental Board recommendation. NSW Health favours mercury-free alternatives in pregnancy, especially the first trimester.
  • Kidney disease: ADA Policy 6.18 (2026) asks dentists to minimise amalgam here and lists severe renal disease as a vulnerable group.
  • Proven allergy: uncommon, and usually a reaction in the cheek, tongue or gum right next to the filling.

For these patients, we work out which mercury-free material suits the tooth: composite, glass ionomer or ceramic.

Should you replace old amalgam fillings that are still intact?

Usually not. If an amalgam is sound and sealed and the tooth around it is healthy, Australian and international guidance advises leaving it alone.

  1. A healthy tooth is lost. The ADA’s consumer site, teeth.org.au, notes that each time a filling is cut out, some tooth goes with it. Each replacement makes the next filling larger.
  2. Mercury vapour rises during removal. The US Food and Drug Administration notes a temporary rise in vapour exposure during removal. NSW Health lists rubber dam, water spray and strong suction among the measures that reduce it.
  3. No health gain has been shown. ADA Policy 6.18 (2026) states there is no evidence that replacing sound amalgam fillings without clinical indications produces a better health outcome.

Some people still prefer a tooth-coloured filling on a tooth that shows. That is a reasonable choice, made knowing that some extra tooth is removed and the new filling may not outlast the old one.

If a filling does need replacing. The old filling is drilled out, usually under local anaesthetic, any decay is removed, and the tooth is rebuilt in a mercury-free material using the vapour-reducing measures above. The size and position of the filling decide how long a filling takes at the dentist.

If a broken filling comes with facial swelling spreading towards the eye or neck, trouble breathing, swallowing or speaking, or you feel very unwell, go to an emergency department or call 000. A fever over 38°C with dental pain or swelling needs same-day dental care, or a GP or emergency department if no dentist is available. After hours, the healthdirect helpline on 1800 022 222 can advise.

Keep, monitor or replace: a decision framework for old silver fillings

The decision rests on what an examination and X-rays show. With an old silver filling, I look at its edges and the tooth wall around it before anything else.

What we find Usual advice Why
Edges sealed, no decay on X-ray, no cracks, no symptoms Keep Removal costs healthy tooth for no clinical gain
Small chip at the edge, fine surface crack lines, mild staining, no decay Monitor Recheck at each examination; a small repair is sometimes possible
Decay under the edge, a broken piece, a cracked cusp, pain on biting, food trapping, or proven allergy Replace The filling or tooth has failed, or there is a medical reason
Large old filling with thin remaining walls Replace with cusp cover An onlay or crown protects weak walls better than another large filling
Lingering pain to hot or cold, tenderness, swelling Assess the nerve first The pulp may need treatment before the tooth is rebuilt

A filling in the first two rows needs watching, not drilling. A regular dental check-up and clean, with X-rays when clinically justified, is where the move from “monitor” to “replace” is usually caught before the filling breaks.

What I would check:

  • Where the crack runs: in the filling only, or through the tooth wall, using magnification and a light shone through the tooth.
  • The edges: a probe and a bitewing X-ray, looking for decay under the margin.
  • Bite tests: biting on a small instrument, one cusp at a time, to reproduce the twinge.
  • The nerve: a cold test and questions about lingering pain.
  • How much tooth is left: thin walls change the options.

The options, depending on those findings:

  1.         Only the filling is cracked, walls thick: a bonded composite filling.
  2.         A cracked cusp or thin walls: a ceramic onlay or a crown to cover the weak cusps.
  3.         A damaged nerve: root canal treatment before the tooth is restored.
  4.         A crack below the gum or through the root: the tooth may not be restorable, and replacement options are discussed.

Each option carries risks, including sensitivity, a nerve that becomes inflamed later, or a crack that keeps growing, and these are explained before anything is decided.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the 2034 phase-out mean I have to remove my amalgam fillings?

No. The 2034 date agreed under the Minamata Convention covers the manufacture, import and export of dental amalgam, to cut mercury pollution. It does not require anyone to have existing fillings removed, and Australian guidance still advises against replacing sound amalgam fillings without a clinical reason.

Can I have an old amalgam filling replaced while I am pregnant?

If the filling is intact, there is no clinical reason to replace it during pregnancy, and removal briefly increases mercury vapour exposure. If it has broken or has decay under it, it still needs treatment. Tell your dentist you are pregnant or breastfeeding so they can plan the timing, material and precautions with you.

Will a new composite filling feel different from my old silver one?

A composite filling is shaped to match your bite, so it should not feel high once adjusted. Some people notice short-term sensitivity to cold. For fillings in general, this usually settles within a few days, sometimes 1 to 2 weeks. If it gets worse or does not settle, contact your dentist so the bite and the nerve can be checked.

Do composite fillings change colour over time?

They can pick up some staining at the surface or edges over the years, and the surrounding tooth can change colour too. A colour change on its own does not mean the filling has failed. If the edges are sealed and there is no decay, polishing or replacing it for appearance is a choice to discuss with your dentist.

How long do glass ionomer fillings last?

SA Dental Service gives an average of 2 to 5 years for glass ionomer cement (accessed November 2026), shorter than its averages for composite and amalgam. Because it is weaker than composite, it is mostly used for baby teeth, fissure sealants and temporary fillings. How long any filling lasts also depends on its size, the bite and your risk of decay.

Conclusion: amalgam fillings in 2026

Intact, well-sealed amalgam fillings usually do not need replacing, and Australian guidance in 2026 still treats amalgam as acceptable where clinically indicated. Composite looks like tooth and needs less drilling, but on current evidence it may need replacing sooner in back teeth. For an old silver filling, the useful question is whether it still does its job, and only an examination answers that.

If you would like your old fillings checked, or want to talk through materials for a new one, book an appointment with our Newtown team or call (02) 9519 2691.

Important information: This article is general information only and does not replace an examination and personalised advice from a registered dental practitioner. Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding, you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner. Results and recovery vary from person to person. The risks of common treatments are outlined in our treatment risks and considerations. All treatment at Blue Tooth Dental is provided by Ahpra-registered dental practitioners.

 

Share this post


Posted on Google Google
Zara hagh profile picture
Zara hagh
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I recently had my Invisalign treatment with Dr. Fatemeh, very affordable and professional. From the moment I walked in, the entire team was so welcoming, friendly, and professional. You can genuinely feel the positive energy in the clinic — it makes such a difference. Dr. Fatemeh is incredibly precise and has amazing attention to detail. She took the time to carefully assess my smile, explain every step clearly, and answer all of my questions. I truly appreciated how thorough and personalised my treatment plan was — it made me feel confident and excited to start my Invisalign journey. If you’re considering Invisalign or looking for a dentist who genuinely cares about quality, detail, and patient comfort, I highly recommend Dr. Fatemeh and her wonderful team. You’ll be in excellent hands!
Posted on Google Google
Thiego Perez profile picture
Thiego Perez
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I will highly recommend to anyone, amazing customer service and amenities
Posted on Google Google
Renata Pedreti profile picture
Renata Pedreti
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
“The professional Maria Julia was incredible in my service. Polite, helpful, and very efficient. Congratulations on having such a great professional on your team.”
Posted on Google Google
antonio teles profile picture
antonio teles
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Best service and structure i’ve ever seen
Posted on Google Google
Heloisa Maria Santos profile picture
Heloisa Maria Santos
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Wonderful service, all the assistants very friendly and attentive.
Posted on Google Google
Maria de Fatima Pedreti profile picture
Maria de Fatima Pedreti
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I FOUND MY DENTIST!!! SHE SOLVED EVERYTHING I NEEDED WITH EXECELLENCE AND DEDICATION! I WOULD GO BACK A THOUSAND TIMES.